Low Carb Sweetener

Low Carb Sweeteners: Which is Best?

by Dee
Published: Updated:

This post may contain affiliate links to products or services that I use and recommend. If you decide to click and purchase, I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. See disclaimer for more information.

Foods made with sugar are off limits when following a low carb diet. For example: soft drinks, cakes, muffins, pastries, ice cream, candy, energy bars…all the yummy stuff! But you can still have your cake and eat it too. That’s where low carb sweeteners come in.

Low carb sweeteners are just as sweet (or sweeter!) than cane sugar, and often have few or zero calories. In addition, most do not raise insulin or blood sugar levels. This is especially important for those with metabolic disorders such as obesity or diabetes.

The market for low carb sweeteners has never been greater. Artificial sweeteners have given way to more natural alternatives. With so many options available, it’s hard to decide which one to use! Below is a brief overview of the options available, and the best uses for each one. However, personal preference and taste will also play a role in which sweetener you prefer.

Artificial vs. Natural Sweeteners

The difference between artificial and natural low carb sweeteners is exactly how it sounds. Artificial sweeteners contain chemicals produced in a lab. Natural sweeteners are plant based. In terms of the Food & Drug Administration (FDA), “natural” means nothing artificial or synthetic (including all color additives regardless of source) has been included in, or has been added to, a food that would not normally be expected to be in that food. I recommend using natural sweeteners whenever possible, although I realize choices can be limited when it comes to pre-packaged foods. Always read the labels! I prefer King Arthur Flour Baking Sugar Alternative, which is a blend of the sweeteners mentioned below.

Safety

Are low carb sweeteners safe to use? Data on the long-term and/or heavy use of low carb sweeteners is contradictory. A 2017 research study found artificial sweeteners associated with obesity, high blood pressure, type 2 diabetes, and heart problems. In addition, low carb sweeteners may cause mild to severe gastrointestinal issues, especially if consumed in large quantities. Click here for the FDA’s list of acceptable daily intake levels.

It’s still too early to know the long-term side effects for newer sweeteners.

The Bottom Line

Low carb sweeteners can aid in the transition to a low carb diet and keep you on track, especially in the early days. However, at least one study confirms they can also stimulate the appetite and trigger overeating. Therefore, it’s best to use them sparingly to supplement whole foods. Experiment to find what works best for you and your body. If you’re not seeing the results you want, low carb sweeteners should be the first to go.

Low Carb Sweetener Comparison

Sugar Alcohols

Sugar alcohols have a similar structure to sugar, but contain an added alcohol molecule. The body does not absorb and metabolize sugar alcohols, so they are often subtracted from total carbs.

SweetenerBest For…Notes
Erythritol
(Swerve)
BakingErythritol is made from fermented corn or cornstarch and provides minimal calories. It is great for baking, since it is a direct replacement in recipes. Some people experience a cooling sensation on the tongue, especially when used in large amounts. 
XylitolIce Cream and Frozen GoodsXylitol is extracted from corn or birch wood and is often used in chewing gum and mouthwash due to its dental health benefits. While it freezes better than other sweeteners, it does contain 2.4 calories per gram. Be careful keeping this in the house if you have pets, as it is highly toxic, especially to dogs.
MaltitolNot RecommendedMaltitol is made from the hydrogenation of the corn-syrup by-product maltose. Since it is less expensive than other sugar alcohols, it is found in many commercial products. Maltitol has been shown to raise blood sugar levels and is a powerful laxative, so be wary of this one!

Plant-Based Low Carb Sweeteners

SweetenerBest For…Notes
Monk FruitBakingAntioxidants extracted from the fruit provide the sweetness. It is commonly blended with other ingredients to reduce intensity, so be sure to check labels. Monk Fruit sweetener is the least likely to cause digestive issues, and does not have a bitter aftertaste.
AlluloseBaked Goods and Ice CreamAllulose is absorbed by the body but is nearly calorie-free since it is not metabolized. It bakes and freezes like sugar. This sweetener is relatively new to the market, and can be expensive.
Yakon SyrupCookies and CakesYakon Syrup is extracted from the yacón plant. It is sweet and dark in color, with the consistency of molasses. Yakon Syrup occurs naturally (like maple syrup), and contains 1.3 calories per gram. It makes a great substitute for molasses in recipes.
Stevia
(SweetLeaf, Truvia)
CoffeeStevia is a natural sweetener extracted from the leaves of a South American shrub. The highly processed product is much sweeter than sugar, so it is often mixed with erythritol. Some experience a metallic or bitter aftertaste.
Agave SyrupNot RecommendedLike high fructose corn syrup, Agave Syrup is 85% fructose. It is best to avoid, since high amounts of fructose are associated with obesity and other serious diseases.

Artificial Low Carb Sweeteners

As mentioned above, these sweeteners are man-made and the jury is still out as to their safety. With more natural alternatives available, I don’t recommend their use.

SweetenerBest For…Notes
Saccharin
(Sweet’n Low)
Not RecommendedThe oldest artificial sweetener, discovered by accident in a lab. Primarily used in diet sodas and sweetener packets, some find it has a metallic aftertaste.
Acesulfame K
(Sunett, Sweet One)
Not RecommendedOften combined with other sweeteners, as it tends to have a bitter aftertaste when used in baking.  Found in light juices and ice cream
Aspartame
(NutraSweet, Equal)
Not RecommendedAspartame breaks down at high temperatures, which makes it unsuitable for baking. It is mainly used in diet sodas and as a tabletop sweetener. Aspartame has the worst reported side effects of all artificial sweeteners and is not safe for those with phenylketonuria.
Sucralose
(Splenda)
Not RecommendedSucralose is made from sugar, but is much sweeter.  It has been linked to an increase in blood glucose levels and a decrease in healthy bacteria in the GI tract. 
Low Carb Sweeteners: Which is Best?

You may also like

Share
Pin
Tweet
Email